Theology, Fantasy, and the Imagination

Theology, Fantasy, and the Imagination analyzes theological, religious, and philosophical themes in classical Christian fantasy, contemporary “post-Christian” fantasy, and fantasy at play in table top games such as Dungeons and Dragons and Magic: the Gathering.

Theology, Fantasy, and the Imagination offers analyses of the theological, philosophical, and religious imagination found in fantasy literature, the theological imagination, and table-top games. Part I offers an invocation to the study through a theological reflection of the “old magic.” Part II analyzes classical Christian fantasy—ranging from dogmatic theological reflection on the fantastic imagination to analyses of C.S. Lewis and J.R.R. Tolkien. Part III analyzes the post-Christian turn in fantasy after about 1960 through today—featuring methodological, theological, and philosophical essays that reflect a movement beyond Christianity in the fantasy literature and writings of Rabbi Shagar, Ursula le Guin, Terry Pratchett, Robert Jordan and David Eddings, and Brandon Sanderson and Orson Scott Card. Part IV closes with two analyses of the religious and philosophical dimensions of table-top games, including Dungeons and Dragons and Magic: the Gathering. Theology, Fantasy, and the Imagination offers astute analyses of how theological fantasy actually is by articulating the religious, philosophical, and theological dimensions of the fantastic imagination.

1. Introduction: Theology, Fantasy, and the Imagination

Andrew D. Thrasher and Austin M. Freeman

Part I: Invocations

2. The Old Magic

Nicholas Adams

Part II: Classical Christian Fantasy: Renewing Christian Imagination

3. Sins of the Imagination

Austin M. Freeman

4. C.S. Lewis, Apologetics, and the Imagination: Breaking the Spell of Secularism

Alison Milbank

5. Between Tolkien and the Philosophers: Greek and Scholastic Theories of Phantasia

Giovanni Carmine Costabile

Part III: Post-Christian Fantasy: Opening the Door Beyond

6. Why Theology Should Always Be Fantasy: Imagination, Fantasy, and Science-Fictional Messianism in the Writings of Rabbi Shagar

Levi Morrow

7. Theology in Shadow: Sin and Redemption in Ursula K. Le Guin’s A Wizard of Earthsea

Oliver D. Crisp

8. Cosmology as Agnostic Self-Actualization in Terry Pratchett’s Discworld

U-Wen Low

9. Fantastic Inter-Religious Resourcement in Robert Jordan and David Eddings

Andrew D. Thrasher

10. The Hero as God: An Exploration of Mormon Soteriology in the Fantasy Novels of Orson Scott Card and Brandon Sanderson

Josh Herring

Part IV: Fantasy at Play: Theologizing with Fantastic Games

11. Imaginative Hermeneutical Theology: Paul Ricoeur and Dungeons & Dragons

Scott Donahue-Martens

12. Magic: The Gathering and Meaning: The Theological Outlook of the World’s Most Complex Game

Jacob Torbeck